Principles of mediation pdf

Looking at statistics of mediation in a community context, it seems that parties and their lawyers look for evaluative mediators who can lead them to a solution. However, this trend seems to be generated by the fact that arbitration became over-regulated, making consumers look for its closest deregulated alternative - evaluative mediation Baruch Bush, There is ample research Kressel, ; Rosenberg, Folberg, ; Charkoudian, ; Quartermain, ; NYPI, speaking to the efficacy of facilitative mediation at a community level.

Mediation has gained popularity and has been increasingly used both locally and internationally. Facilitative mediation is the approach that better reflects the internationally acknowledged principles of impartiality, confidentiality and self-determination NY State ADR Office, ; European Commission, ; United Nations, and is supported by experts like Curle who would argue that manipulative evaluative styled mediation cannot be considered mediation. According to Galton , cited by Riskin, , p.

There are a number of critiques to specific mediation approaches and more generally to mediation as a method for conflict resolution. In facilitative mediation, concepts of justice and procedure are substituted by focus on interpretation and communication.

Kovach, Love, A mediator that evaluates is not impartial, and can trigger adversarial behaviour and lack of trust in the mediator and in the process Kovach, Love, Burton and Dukes in fact distinguish between disputes , underlying which is an issue of competing interests, and conflicts, underlying which is an issue about needs, the same material, acceptance, and access needs defined by Azar This could require changes in policies, institutions and even in the systems concerned.

In this sense, ADR and mediation can actually be used to serve those who want to escape justice to advance their own interests through a process that does not rely on legal norms, but allows on bargaining that can easily favour the stronger parties Burton, Dukes, This attitude is particularly evident in the case of legal transplants.

It is no surprise that in international disputes, disadvantaged parties typically have a preference for court proceedings while parties who are politically and economically stronger will prefer ADR Greco, Even an ombudsman, an ADR figure specifically appointed to address public grievances against a government or a specific institution Burton, Dukes, , can be used to deflect attention from a structurally violent system to place the blame on low-level bureaucrats, especially in non-democratic states Caiden , Zagoria, As Burton, also Azar states that mediations can foster short-term changes, but for substantial change to take place, fundamental structural issues must be addressed.

Adwan S. Azar, E. Aldershot: Dartmouth. Bartunek, J. The Journal of Conflict Resolution, Vol. Baruch Bush, R. Beardsley, K. Bercovitch J. Burton, J. Basingstoke: The Macmillan Press Ltd. In: Groom, Light eds. London: Pinter Publishers. Caiden, G. Westport: Greenwood Press.

Charkoudian, L. Conflict Resolution Quarterly, Vol. Commons, J. American Journal of Sociology, Vol. Curle, A. Berg Publishers Ltd. In: Liebman eds. Mediation in Context. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd. Egeland J. In: Crocker, Hampson, Aall eds. Whilst mediation should always be facilitated by a skilled and impartial third party, and not every conflict will be appropriate to apply mediation, the underlying principles of mediation can be an excellent resource in addressing conflict in everyday life.

A willingness to work together and maintaining a solution focus can often lead to a successful outcome. Your email address will not be published. Home Student Support Centres. During the mediation, private meetings between the mediator and either party can take place at the request of either party or the mediator. The content of the agreement is created and agreed only by the parties themselves, not the mediator. This document will be signed by both parties and remains confidential unless both parties request otherwise.

We regret we are not able to respond to requests for specific legal or HR queries and recommend that professional advice is obtained before relying on information supplied anywhere within this article.

The main content of this article was provided by Mags Camody. Email Address Password Remember me. Not registered with us? Try for free.